Toronto Maple Leafs: Is Eric Staal Worth the Cost?

If you haven’t heard the news by now, the answer is simple: you’re not a true fan of the Toronto Maple Leafs. (They should consume your entire life.)

Eric Staal is coming to Toronto or at least that’s how some Leafs fans have interpreted the news.

As reported in several places yesterday, Eric Staal is open to the idea of joining the Leafs. He’d have to waive his no-trade clause to make this happen, but that’s a mere formality at this point.

Eric Staal (James Guillory-US PRESSWIRE)

In other words, he’s willing to do it and that’s enough for some Leafs fans.

Hence, the excitement.

Hence, the delirium.

Lost in all the craziness, however, is one very important question: would this trade actually benefit Toronto?

(Stuck at the bottom of the standings, burdened with unaffordable contracts and reduced to irrelevancy once again, there’s no doubt the trade would benefit the Carolina Hurricanes.)

Eric Staal: The Numbers

At 29 years of age, Stall is still an attractive option at centre, but his prime years might be beyond him. He’s best known as the baby-faced kid who helped the Hurricanes win their first and only Stanley Cup in 2006.

That was eight seasons ago and a very special one for Staal, who collected 100 points (45 goals, 55 assists) in 82 games. Since this magical run, the general trend in terms of Staal’s production has been downward: he’s generally hovered just above, at or below the point-per-game mark, but last season he fell to 61 points (21 goals, 40 assists) in 79 games.

Tyler Bozak (THW)

If this proves the new norm for Staal, it means he’s not a clear upgrade over Tyler Bozak or Nazem Kadri – the top two centremen on the Leafs’ depth chart – when we’re talking points. There’s a level of maturity and experience Staal possesses that escapes the two Leafs, but that’s about it and it comes at quite the high cost, too.

For those who want to argue Staal isn’t surrounded by strong players in Carolina, please take a moment to consider the presence of Jeff Skinner, Jordan Staal, Alexander Semin and Justin Faulk. (Sadly, John-Michael Liles doesn’t quite make the cut.)

Eric Staal: The Contract

Two years (including the present one) at the respective base-salary costs of $9,250,000 million and $9,500,000 million remain on Staal’s current contract. That’s a lot of dough.

Carolina would almost certainly have to eat some of this contract but the Leafs, pressed up against the very top of the salary cap limits thanks to David Clarkson, would have to create some room, too. Does this mean moving Bozak and his very reasonable contract in return?

Bozak has four years left on his contract (including the present one), which would hand the advantage to Carolina.

David Clarkson (John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports)

If the Hurricanes are looking for a temporary replacement or someone young who can grow into Staal’s old role, what are the options? Kadri? William Nylander? At this point in the surprisingly long NHL career of Staal, that’d be like trading a delicious, ripe apple for next season’s apple seeds. It doesn’t make sense.

Finally, if there’s one overall factor working against the Staal trade talk, it’s the Clarkson contract. The Leafs can’t afford the financial or reputational costs of another blunder like this.

In an odd way, this becomes Clarkson’s greatest contribution to the Leafs: restraint in the face of stupidity from the management team.

That’s my Clarkson!

Author information

William Wilson

William has been a lifelong Leafs fan. He's also been depressed for most of his life. His columns try to combine humour and insight, but there are no guarantees. He looks forward to sharing his passion for the Blue & White with you, and he looks equally forward to hearing about your passion for everyone's favourite team. Vive la Leafs Nation.

| Twitter | Facebook |